Coaching Information

Why Bosses Dont Get All the News


Not long ago, a friend who works in television complained that the industry has no interest in real business stories. And, I had to agree with him, since we don't see much coverage that doesn't involve stock prices or some sort of scandal.

But, there has been one important exception. A few years ago, the British Broadcasting Corporation (BBC) began airing a business show that became as popular as some of its regular prime-time fare (American and Canadian television networks followed up with their own versions of the program).

Fast Company magazine told us about the BBC program, which sees CEOs leaving their corner offices for a stint on the front lines. And, as they work on the front lines, the cameras are rolling.

For many, if not all CEOs who participated, the experience was a great eye-opener. According to the magazine, "Almost without exception, CEOs learn a lesson in communication. 'We find people at the heart of every organization who know exactly what's right and what's wrong with it,' says [Robert] Thirkell [who produces the show]. 'But between them and the bosses is a layer of people -- those whose careers depend on sanitizing that information. Bosses are always surprised at how much knowledge exists further down the ladder.'"

With that in mind, let's spend a minute or two thinking about the barriers to good upward communication. But, rather than blame middle management, which seems to be one of the themes of the program, we'll look at structural issues.

First, upward communication involves the aggregation of information or data. For example, a supervisor reports on the collective efforts of five front-line staff, a manager aggregates the data of five supervisors, and a vice-president aggregates the information provided by five managers.

As the information gets aggregated this way, it loses most of its context and richness. By richness, I'm talking about the anecdotal and personal knowledge that front-line workers gather and build from continuous interactions with customers or users. Obviously, most CEOs don't have time to read reports comprised of hundreds of anecdotes; they want summaries of the information.

Second, as information or data moves upward, it tends to be slotted into pre-existing categories. Employees on the front-lines know and understand the nuances of each customer story; it reflects, to a greater or lesser extent, the personal relationship between worker and customer. But, there's no place for nuance in weekly reports.

Third, upward communication normally deals with compliance, rather than competitive or operational intelligence. Managers use information moving up the hierarchy to determine how well instructions have been followed. When they want competitive or operational information they often use different means, such as bringing in consultants or commissioning studies.

It's always tempting to attribute communication failures to moral failures by managers, but if you really want to understand communication failures, you should start by looking for structural hurdles.

In summary, CEOs who spend time on the front lines will undoubtedly be in for many surprises. But, if they want to get the news from the front lines, they'll need to address the structural nature of upward communication.

About The Author

Robert F. Abbott writes and publishes Abbott's Communication Letter. Each week subscribers receive, at no charge, a new communication tip that helps them lead or manage more effectively. Click here for more information: http://www.CommunicationNewsletter.com

abbottr@managersguide.com


MORE RESOURCES:

USA TODAY

Sabres coach Ruff day to day after breaking 3 ribs
Wall Street Journal
AP BUFFALO, NY — Buffalo Sabres coach Lindy Ruff is still in severe pain, and it's unclear when he'll be able to resume coaching a day after breaking three ribs during an on-ice collision with defenseman Jordan Leopold. General manager Darcy Regier on ...
Injured Sabres, Oilers coaches day-to-dayUSA TODAY
Sabres assistant Patrick to coach if broken ribs sideline RuffTonawanda News
Sabres coach Lindy Ruff listed day to day after breaking 3 ribs in on-ice ...570 News

all 254 news articles »


ESPN

Jim Calhoun vows return to coaching
ESPN
By Andy Katz Connecticut coach Jim Calhoun plans on getting through the latest health crisis with his back and returning to coaching when he is physically able. The Hall of Fame coach was diagnosed with spinal stenosis last week and took a medical ...
Calhoun not retiring, seeks care for back issuesUSA TODAY (blog)

all 205 news articles »


CBSSports.com (blog)

USC WR coach Gilmore headed to Oakland
CBSSports.com (blog)
Just a few days after losing linebackers coach Joe Barry to the NFL, USC is down another staff member after wide receiver Ted Gilmore accepted the same position with the Oakland Raiders, a source told CBSSports.com. Gilmore, 44, came to USC just a year ...
USC loses another football assistant, receivers coach Ted GilmoreLos Angeles Times
Source: Ted Gilmore leaves USCESPN

all 19 news articles »


Chicago Tribune

New Bears QB coach has ties to Cutler
Chicago Tribune
Jay Cutler has had a strained relationship with offensive coaches for the Chicago Bears, but Tuesday's hiring of Jeremy Bates as the team's quarterbacks coach gives him someone he's worked closely with in the past. Bates worked with Cutler in Denver ...
Bears hire Bates as new QB coachChicago Bear Report (subscription)

all 180 news articles »


NBCSports.com

Iowa promotes Parker to DC in staff shuffle
ESPN (blog)
After spending the past 24 seasons coaching defensive backs, the past 13 at Iowa, Parker now will lead the Hawkeyes' defense. He replaces Norm Parker, who announced his retirement in December. Although Phil Parker, who isn't related to Norm, ...
Could the Patriots lose tight ends coach Brian Ferentz to Iowa?WEEI.com
Ferentz staying in family with coaching hiresHuskerExtra.com
Iowa promotes Parker to defensive coordinatorSioux City Journal
The Gazette: Eastern Iowa Breaking News and Headlines -Bleacher Report -Big Ten Network
all 47 news articles »


Christian Science Monitor

Is New York Giants Coach Tom Coughlin a Hall of Famer?
Los Angeles Times
Writers from around the Tribune Co. discuss the Hall of Fame credentials for New York Giants Coach Tom Coughlin, who just won his second Super Bowl with the New York team. Check back throughout the day for more responses and join the discussion by ...
Patriots players, coach, fans ask 'what if?'Worcester Telegram
New England Patriots' coach and owner still proud of their team – NFL news Updatebettor.com (blog)
Coaching contrasts of Super Bowl 2012: the 'hoodie' vs. the 'colonel'Christian Science Monitor
SB Nation -USA TODAY (blog) -Bleacher Report
all 22,411 news articles »


Las Vegas Sun

UNLV football shuffles coaching deck
Las Vegas Review-Journal
By Mark Anderson UNLV football coach Bobby Hauck said it was time to "freshen up our approach a little bit," so he changed both coordinators Tuesday but kept his staff intact. He promoted tight ends coach Brent Myers to offensive coordinator and ...
Coach shuffling for UNLV staff results in new offensive, defensive coordinatorsLas Vegas Sun
UNLV shuffles coaching staff following dismal seasonCBSSports.com
FOX5 Vegas - KVVUUNLV football shuffles staff, names new coordinatorsKVVU Las Vegas

all 41 news articles »


Silver and Black report

Loss of Tarver tough, but not devastating
ESPN (blog)
You get good, and then the getting gets good for other teams to come in and start picking off assistant coaches. Stanford is no exception. It happened last year with the head coach. And another successful season means another round of the coaching ...
Jason Tarver could bring a new defensive schemeSilver and Black report
Oakland Raiders Take Another Coaching Risk In Hiring Jason Tarver To ...SB Nation
Football: Co-coordinator Tarver leaving to run Raiders' defenseThe Stanford Daily
Thoughts from the Dark Side -Bleacher Report
all 200 news articles »


Milwaukee Journal Sentinel

Rodgers likes idea of QB coach with playing experience
Green Bay Press Gazette
Green Bay Packers quarterback Aaron Rodgers said he hasn't been told who will replace Tom Clements as the team's quarterbacks coach but hinted Tuesday he would prefer someone with playing experience. Tight ends coach Ben McAdoo has been considered a ...
On the Packers' highly regarded assistantsESPN (blog)

all 32 news articles »


USA TODAY

Report: Todd Haley to join Steelers coaching staff
WEEI.com
By Arielle Aronson Former Kansas City head coach Todd Haley may have found a new home. According to Mark Carman of 610 AM in Kansas City, Haley will join the Steelers coaching staff as the new offensive coordinator. The move has yet to be announced by ...
Todd Haley resurfaces in PittsburghESPN (blog)
Roundup: Haley reportedly a Steeler; coordinators get jobsUSA TODAY
Todd Haley Hired As Steelers Offensive Coordinator, Cardinals' List Cut Down ...Revenge of the Birds
Bolts from the Blue -Bleacher Report
all 417 news articles »

Google News

home | site map
© 2007